Baby Einstein Refunds

Congratulations to the Campaign for a Commercial-Free Childhood (CCFC) !

Note: for a list of studies looking at the effects of TV on very young children see: http://www.tvsmarter.com/documents/young.html 

CCFC successfully pressured “the Walt Disney Company to offer a full refund to anyone who purchased a Baby Einstein DVD in the last five years.”

This is in addition to their ”2006 Federal Trade Commission complaint” which forced Disney to stop making false claims that Baby Einstein DVDs were educational.

From The New York Times article on the Baby Einstein Refunds:

Last year, lawyers threatened a class-action lawsuit for unfair and deceptive practices unless Disney agreed to refund the full purchase price to all who bought the videos since 2004. “The Walt Disney Company’s entire Baby Einstein marketing regime is based on express and implied claims that their videos are educational and beneficial for early childhood development,” a letter from the lawyers said, calling those claims “false because research shows that television viewing is potentially harmful for very young children.”

Perhaps “Baby Einstein” should be renamed “Baby Bozo” !

But it was the comments that were the most fun, here are a few that I especially liked:

New tvSmarter Pages

I’ve added a few new pages to tvSmarter.com, hope you’ll check them out.

Playing versus TV

http://www.tvsmarter.com/documents/playing.html

Young Children (babies & toddlers) and TV

http://www.tvsmarter.com/documents/young.html

My Democracy page had gotten too unwieldy, so I divvied it up into:

Democracy & TV

http://www.tvsmarter.com/documents/democracy.html

Civil Society & TV

http://www.tvsmarter.com/documents/civil.html

Propaganda, the News & TV

http://www.tvsmarter.com/documents/propaganda.html

Covert Propaganda & TV

http://www.tvsmarter.com/documents/propaganda2.html

Torture & TV

http://www.tvsmarter.com/documents/torture.html

Please let me know if I should change and/or add anything or any other suggestion.

Neighborhood Hero

American Boys at Play

Originally uploaded by cobalt123

 

 

 

Parenting used to be a much easier endeavor. Before the era of endless TV, parents just let their kids go outside and play. There was safety in numbers, and almost always plenty of kids outside to play with.

Not anymore. Now, if you send you child outside to play, chances are he/she won’t find anyone to play with. The neighborhood kids are mostly  hidden away, on the couch, watching the tube (with a bit of video gaming thrown in).

Mike Lanza is doing his best to change all that (one neighborhood at a time).

Excerpts from a San Francisco Chronicle article, From landscape to playscape:

Lanza, the father of three boys, built the outdoor wonderland with a mission in mind. He wants children to rediscover the joys of playing freely outside, so he’s given all the kids in his neighborhood an open invitation to play in what he calls his “front yard family room.” And the play equipment in his backyard, which would make the White House’s youngest residents envious, also is accessible to all.

Old-Fashioned Childhood:

Like many parents, Lanza, 46, looks back fondly on his own childhood spent playing with friends in the neighborhood – tag, pick-up football, hide-and-seek – knocking on doors to swell the numbers, and all the while untethered from parents. The key difference between then and now, he says, was the freedom children enjoyed.

“Kids sought out things to do that were fun,” he says. “They didn’t always ask their parents’ permission, and they didn’t have the indoor distractions like video games or computers, nor all the organized activities parents orchestrate now. So they went outside and came up with things to do.”

Neighborhood Culture

Along with creating the physical elements of a communal play environment, Lanza has been working to solidify a kid culture in the neighborhood – spending time with parents and kids, hanging out on evenings in the front yard, and throwing spontaneous potlucks for people to get to know one another.

“Weather permitting, our two boys are practically always outside in the front or backyard if they’re home and if they’re not eating or sleeping,” he says. “And pretty much every evening our kids are playing with other kids, usually at our place, and sometimes at a neighbor’s house. It can be very free-flowing and spontaneous.”

And not surprising:

It probably goes without saying that the Lanza family doesn’t own a TV or any electronic games.

 

Floor Games and Sand Play

Hero’s Home

Originally uploaded by Eric K.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Neil Postman, argues in his book “The Disappearance of Childhood” that the idea of childhood as a separate, innocent time for play and learning is very much a recent invention.

In hunter gatherer societies children have plenty of time to play and also to learn naturally from older children and adults going about their business.

http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/freedom-learn/200808/children-educate-themselves-iii-the-wisdom-hunter-gatherers

But, as Postman convincingly argues, the Middles Ages (or the Dark Ages) was a very harsh time for children. Children were expected to work from a very early age, and work hard, and parents were free to do with them as they like. At age 7, they were considered to have reached the age of reason and were given the same sentence for any crime as adults (including hanging for theft).

It wasn’t until the 1600s that the modern conception of childhood started to come about. Parents and community groups and churches opened schools and eventually playgrounds. During the Victorian Era especially, Children’s Literature thrived along with the concept of childhood as an innocent time for play and learning, to be protected from adult concerns. School nevertheless was often harsh, but was a huge step up from factory work and mining and the many other forms of child labor.

 

Excerps from “The Serious Need for Play”

Last Day of School

Originally uploaded by K Chu

 

 

 

 

 Excerpts from an article published in Scientific American Mind (February 2009) called “The Serious Need for Play“.

Note, these are just excerpts, please click on the link to read the full, very fascinating, article.

 

The Serious Need for Play

Free, imaginative play is crucial for normal social, emotional and cognitive development. It makes us better adjusted, smarter and less stressed.

By Melinda Wenner   

 

Key Concepts

- Childhood play is crucial for social, emotional and cognitive ­development.

- Imaginative and rambunctious “free play,” as opposed to games or structured activities, is the most essential type.

- Kids and animals that do not play when they are young may grow into anxious, socially maladjusted adults.

 

Free Play

“Free play,” as scientists call it, is critical for becoming socially adept, coping with stress and building cognitive skills such as problem solving. Research into animal behavior confirms play’s benefits and establishes its evolutionary importance: ultimately, play may provide animals (including humans) with skills that will help them survive and reproduce.

Most psychologists agree that play affords benefits that last through adulthood, but they do not always agree on the extent to which a lack of play harms kids—particularly because, in the past, few children grew up without ample frolicking time. But today free play may be losing its standing as a staple of youth. According to a paper published in 2005 in the Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine, children’s free-play time dropped by a quarter between 1981 and 1997. Concerned about getting their kids into the right colleges, parents are sacrificing playtime for more structured activities. As early as preschool, youngsters’ after-school hours are now being filled with music lessons and sports—reducing time for the type of imaginative and rambunctious cavorting that fosters creativity and cooperation.

This creative aspect is key because it challenges the developing brain more than following predetermined rules does. In free play, kids use their imagination and try out new activities and roles.

 

Post Turn-off Week – May 2009

Playing hopscotch on the beach

Originally uploaded by annulla

Every year when Turn-off Week rolls around, my tvSmarter.com pageviews go way up. This year especially, the pageviews were double and even triple what they normally are. And since most of my pageviews are the result of internet searches, I think this is evidence that Turn-off Week does indeed succeed at increasing awareness of the harmful effects of too much TV (and other screentime).

Congratulation to Screentime and all the participants for another great Turn-off Week !

Congratulation also to Sarah of Unplug-Your Kids for her excellent Turn-off Week Blog Challenge.

Sarah recaps here (with quotes and links to plenty of very entertaining stories):

http://www.unplugyourkids.com/2009/04/27/so-how-did-it-go/

http://www.unplugyourkids.com/2009/05/06/and-the-winner-is-3/

http://www.unplugyourkids.com/2009/05/06/another-non-bloggers-story-jeanna-from-new-zealand/

http://www.unplugyourkids.com/2009/05/03/baking-soda-boats/

http://www.unplugyourkids.com/2009/05/02/a-non-blogger-report/

Regarding Sarah’s turn-off week, she made this encouraging observation:

ENCOURAGING NOTE:  One thing I have observed with my children which might be encouraging to other parents, is that once they get over the first hump of reading fluency, they seem to have much less interest in videos and spend a great deal of their non-play time reading.

This was certainly true with my 8 year-old daughter when she became comfortable with independent reading, but she was never a huge video watcher to begin with.

It was far more remarkable with my 6 year-old son.  He was always the one who would have been Mr. TV had I allowed it.  In the past few months he has suddenly taken off with his reading and is rarely found without a chapter book in his hand.  He honestly seems to have forgotten that the TV ever existed.  My husband and I are absolutely astonished!